Thank you!

Dear Readers,

Thank you, indeed. The number of page views crossed 15K on Nov. 1, 2016.

A compilation of the blog posts up to first quarter of 2016 has been published and is available on Smashwords, Amazon (Kindle store), and Google Books.
Showing posts with label Public Sector Banks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Public Sector Banks. Show all posts

Thursday, March 31, 2016

Bank Nationalization in Retrospect

Banks were nationalized by Mrs Indira Gandhi with much fanfare.  It was done with a view to replace the class banking practiced by the then private banks with mass banking.  Currently the term mass banking has been replaced by a more sophisticated one, that is, financial inclusion.  This was a laudable objective indeed and still remains laudable and only marginally fulfilled.  Else, why would there be such hue and cry about financial inclusion after more than 4 decades of bank nationalization?

Looking back, it seems very clear that this was a master stroke by the shrewd political class for helping crony capitalists drain the public exchequer.  All talk about mass banking was merely a facade.  The unfulfilled mass banking agenda is being now carried forward for setting up smaller banks with limited functionality like payment banks etc.

In a recent TV debate on the Mallya debacle, one of the speakers pointed out that it is generally believed that the global banking crisis a few years ago left India untouched.  While governments world over had to pump in huge amounts of money to rescue some of the banks, nothing of the sort had to be done in India.  He went on to say that this is fallacious.  According to him Indian public sector banks face this crisis every year because of large loans being written off and large sacrifices being made for corporate debt restructuring etc.  And they are rescued each year by the government by recapitalizing the banks.  Thus nationalization did not help the agriculturists or the poor common man so much as it helped corporates having good liaison with the politicians to milk the public exchequer.  To be fair it must be said that the banks merely served as a convenient conduit.  But has the conduit too been damaged in the process?  We may have to wait for some more time to find out.

This must be the reason why politicians of all hues, and not merely the leftists who control the trade unions in these banks, have no real interest in privatizing the banks.  Though, it must be said to their credit that they do occasionally make the right kind of noises in this matter.

The massive fraud, which perhaps overshadows all other mega scams thus far, has now been uncovered and the astronomical amounts involved are staring us in the face.  I do not know if the sums involved are giving the government a cold feet too.  Do they still have the capability to recapitalize the banks to the extent required?  Or is the ground being prepared for the depositors to take a haircut?

As a retired person living on his precious savings and interest thereon, the very thought gives me the shivers.

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Trade Unions and Wages in Public Sector Banks in India

Trade unions in the banking industry in India are like living fossils from an age long past.  They have internalized a few moves which probably helped them survive in the past and are utterly unable to learn new responses to today's world that has outevolved them.

The same pattern of slogan raising followed by strikes and a show of fighting it out has been going on for decades.  This rowdyism had alienated bankers from the public at large.  The public thought that bankers were callous and too well paid for what they were doing.  Even though the pay scales have since then plummeted to the bottom most rung, the impression in public mind persists, probably as a reaction to persistence of the fossilized behavior of unions from a distant past.

Everyone wonders, except the wise old union leaders, about the purpose served by one day strikes indulged in by them and stretching the negotiations over years.  This does help the industry as it saves funds on wages for the days of strike and interest on deferred payouts because of protracted negotiations.  It used to hurt other stakeholders like the workers and the public.  They often wondered if there was something going on behind the curtains that somehow benefited the unions and encouraged them to behave the way they did and still do.  Today it doesn't hurt the public much thanks to vast strides in banking technology.  The workers are the sole sufferers.

It would be far better if the workers pooled their salaries for a few days instead of going on strike.  This fund could then be used to insert advertisements in prominent newspapers.  The objective should be to educate the public and the political class about the far higher risks in their job profile and a far lower pay than many others in far easier jobs.

When banks were nationalized, bankers used to draw salaries which exceeded their counterparts in state and central governments.  Naturally this could not go on and soon a committee said that these should be at par with those drawn by counterparts in government.  And once the parity was achieved, they ruthlessly pushed down the wages in the industry which today are the lowest in government and public sector.  This was done all too quietly.  Even the political masters of these scheming and plotting bureaucrats still think that bankers are too well paid.  They hardly have the time to go through the facts.  The same applies to the public at large.  Hence the need for education through massive advertising.

It is a common sense principle that those who deal in money must be paid reasonably well.  Once the public is convinced that those whom they trust with their money are not paid well enough, their sympathy may help swing the outcome of negotiations.

I would further suggest that the trade unions should give up their addiction to negotiations.  The disastrous results are there for all to see.  It will be a far superior option to just ask for total parity with central government employees.  After all isn't this what the bureaucrats wanted in the beginning?  Once you have the parity, you will have no reason or need to negotiate.

But before this can happen, bank employees must educate and enlighten the customers, public and politicians on their current plight.  Striking work is no way to do that.