Thank you!

Dear Readers,

Thank you, indeed. The number of page views crossed 15K on Nov. 1, 2016.

A compilation of the blog posts up to first quarter of 2016 has been published and is available on Smashwords, Amazon (Kindle store), and Google Books.
Showing posts with label checks and balances. Show all posts
Showing posts with label checks and balances. Show all posts

Saturday, August 25, 2018

An Informal Presidential System Without Requisite Checks and Balances

Whenever a strong leader makes it to the top, her / his followers raise a demand for the Presidential system of Government.  It happened in Indira Gandhi's time and we have heard the voices in the current times too.

What has happened in reality is that we are already into a semi-Presidential system.  Do you say how?  Well, now every political party requires not only a symbol but also a face, a face for the topmost position if it gets a majority.  It is this face that does most of the campaigning, the actual candidates from different constituencies being of little consequence.  If there is resentment in a some constituencies agaist the local candidate on account of his being corrupt or a known criminal, the voters are plainly told that you are NOT voting for that candidate but for "the face:"  That the candidates are merely hands, mere instruments, in the hands of the face which is the seat of the brain too that commands these mere limbs.

A reaffirmation of faith in the true democratic principles is heard only when the face is uncertain of attracting the masses at the state or national level, as the case may be.  In such a case the concerned party will say that a person will be chosen for the top position in a democratic manner by the elected representatives and that the electorate should vote on the basis of policies and the manifesto and not personalities.  Otherwise as we said, they plead for one country one leader or somethig to the same effect.

In this day of strong leaders, the semi-presidential system is doing harm to the system which was not designed for this form of government.  As most of the legislators owe their victory to a single person and hence have little voice of their own, the whole system becomes a hostage to the strong leader.  This further fuels this person's ambitions for consolidating his hold and this leads to a corrosive approach to the other counterbalancing players and institutions in the system such as judiciary or media etc.  This would not happen if the person at the top felt that he didn't own the legislators but owed his position to them.  And in this case, the legislators will exercise the first level of control on the ambitions of the person at the top and keep it from trying to subjugate all checks and balances.

If we see merit in having a strong leader then we should also consider suitably modifying the Constitution to implement checks and balances that meet the requirements of a Presidential form of government.  Else we might end up having worst of both the worlds.


Sunday, October 18, 2015

NJAC - A Citizen's Views

Today the legislature and the executive are elected by the public while the top judiciary appoints itself.  The executive and the legislature are seen by the long suffering public as going berserk and having no intentions of correcting their course.  The judiciary, especially the lower one, too is seen suffering from similar ills.

However in many cases the self-appointed top judiciary is the only institution that is able to exercise some check on the legislature and the executive. And hence any attempt by the executive to insinuate itself into the process of appointments in the judiciary must be opposed tooth and nail.

And, yet, it cannot be gainsaid that an institution as important as the judiciary cannot be left to its own devices for appointments without any external controls.  After all, we are opposing any role for the government in the appointment of judiciary on the grounds of checks and balances only.

Under these circumstances I feel that instead of giving the government any role in selection of judges for High and Supreme courts, the role should be given to the public itself.  A list of desirous and eligible persons may be prepared and their CV and achievements put on a website.  Thereafter the concerned public, state or the whole country, should vote for them.  Any campaigning must be through the website, national TV, SMS and electronic messengers only.  The voting must be done through mobiles only to cut down on all the hassles associated with setting up voting booths.  Now that voter id cards are being linked to Aadhaar, voter ids are automatically getting linked to voters' mobile numbers.  This would be a far better alternative to any meddling by the government.

Do you agree?